# Exploring the Concept of Universes Within Black Holes
Written on
Chapter 1: The Black Hole Big Bang Theory
The hypothesis that we reside within a black hole is more plausible than it may initially appear. Black holes distort both space and time to such an extent that they effectively switch roles. For an observer falling into a black hole, the radial direction toward the singularity transforms into a temporal dimension, while the time dimension behaves like space.
Key predictions from this phenomenon include the idea that, once inside the event horizon of a black hole, (a) escape is impossible because the only exit leads backward in time, and (b) the singularity represents a "spacelike" region of spacetime that acts as a barrier. Anything that crosses this boundary meets the singularity at various spatial coordinates along its length.
Another significant prediction is that the infinitely compressed core of the black hole is an event in the future for the falling observer. Upon reaching this singularity, the laws of physics as we understand them cease to function, leaving the nature of events afterward a mystery. While future theories of quantum gravity might provide insight, our current understanding is lacking.
The essence of the Black Hole Big Bang Theory (BHBBT) posits that matter from a "mother universe" collapses into a black hole. To someone in the mother universe, the singularity exists as a single point in space. Yet, for individuals within the "daughter universe," this point transforms into their initial moment in time, effectively becoming t=0. Thus, what was once a spatial singularity becomes a temporal one, akin to the Big Bang.
Consequently, any matter entering from the mother universe vanishes from its realm and re-emerges at t=0 in the daughter universe, albeit in a thoroughly mixed form. Additionally, what emerges during the Big Bang is not limited to the matter present at the black hole's formation; it includes all matter that has ever fallen into it. This occurs because time at the singularity exists perpendicularly to time in the mother universe.
The capacity for one universe to contain another relates to the peculiarities of how time and space can be warped, stretched, and twisted. What might seem like a dead-end at a black hole's center could instead serve as a gateway to the genesis of a new universe.
This interconnectedness opens the door to numerous universes, where mothers give rise to daughters, which in turn can spawn more daughters, creating an infinite chain. Thus, rather than being merely 13.8 billion years old, the entire interconnected cosmos could possess an infinite age, with time paths extending endlessly into the past across different universes.
This concept diverges from the Many Worlds Interpretation of quantum mechanics, which I have critiqued in previous articles. Here, there isn't a continuous splitting of universes based on quantum measurements. Instead, the process unfolds through black hole formation, with each universe being unique, although daughter universes may share some characteristics with their progenitors. Importantly, this means that duplicates of individuals do not coexist in these alternate realities.
Some theorists have suggested that a natural selection process may occur among these universes, as only those capable of forming black holes can reproduce. This notion could also offer a potential resolution to the anthropic principle, which seeks to explain human existence, since each universe may have varying laws of physics. Just as not every planet can support life, not all universes can sustain it—no Many Worlds interpretation is needed, just many distinct universes coexisting within a single spacetime.
Section 1.1: The Standard Big Bang Model
The Standard Big Bang (SBB) model posits that the universe, encompassing time, space, and matter, originated from a singular point approximately 13.8 billion years ago. From the perspective of General Relativity, Einstein's theory of gravity, space itself was compressed into that singularity. As time commenced, space began to expand, carrying matter along with it. This expansion continues to this day, evidenced by the observation that distant galaxies are moving away from us. Furthermore, galaxies that are farther away recede at a faster rate, consistent with a universe in expansion. A common analogy is that of dots on an inflating balloon—when the balloon expands, all dots move apart, with those farther apart moving faster.
Where is the center of the universe?
The Big Bang's origin point is not located anywhere in space but exists at a moment in time, t=0, during the Big Bang event. The balloon analogy is beneficial here; the center of the balloon is not situated on its surface. Space can be conceptualized as the surface of the balloon extended into a three-dimensional realm, with the past resembling the interior.
Conversely, black holes have their centers defined by a point in space, r=0, relative to their singularity coordinates, highlighting their fundamental difference from the Big Bang singularity.
Section 1.2: How Can We Be Inside a Black Hole?
One peculiar aspect of general relativity is its capacity to bend space and time to the extent that they can interchange their roles. This is where the signature of the spacetime metric, which defines the behavior of space and time, changes.
Intense concentrations of matter can warp space and time, altering the meaning of distance for different observers. For an observer situated outside the black hole, known as the "far observer," the singularity appears as a point in space. In contrast, for an observer within the event horizon—termed the "near observer"—the signs of the radial and temporal elements of the spacetime metric reverse. Thus, for the near observer, the singularity represents a point in time in the future.
The BHBBT proposes that upon reaching certain singularities, matter transitions to a new universe where time at the singularity serves as that universe's inception point.
To visualize this concept, imagine an ant traversing a table. As it crawls, it descends a slope that becomes increasingly steep until it reaches a vertical drop-off. Instead of concluding at that point, however, it opens into a conical expansion. Through a remarkable twist of quantum mechanics, the ant passes through the point and emerges into the cone, entering a new universe that exists perpendicularly to the one it just left.
Chapter 2: Advantages of the BHBBT
The BHBBT addresses several shortcomings of the Standard Big Bang model concerning the universe's formation. One key issue with the SBB model is its inability to clarify the universe's remarkable homogeneity. Observations of the early universe, particularly through the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), suggest a thorough mixing of the universe's contents, often referred to as the horizon problem.
The Horizon Problem
The horizon problem pertains to causality. The vast region over which the CMB appears homogeneous is much larger than would be feasible under ordinary causal conditions, limited by the speed of light. The prevailing solution to this dilemma is the inflationary theory, which posits that space underwent rapid expansion, carrying light and matter along, leading to a thoroughly mixed universe—akin to a cosmic blender.
However, the inflationary theory fails to resolve several other issues, including the fluctuation problem, the super-Planck scale physics problem, and the initial singularity problem. While it addresses some concerns, it does not provide a comprehensive solution.
The horizon problem indicates that two regions of the universe observed in the CMB should not be correlated, as they would have only had about 300,000 years post-Big Bang to communicate. Yet, observations show a significant degree of correlation across the universe.
The BHBBT addresses this issue by highlighting that matter falling into the black hole has ample time to interact with other incoming matter before reaching the singularity. Although this interaction is not registered on the daughter universe's clock, it occurs in a quasi-time that exists within the event horizon, situated between the mother and daughter universes.
The Flatness Problem
Another challenge facing the SBB model is the flatness problem. Observations indicate that the universe appears flat, suggesting a matter density that aligns precisely with the critical value of 1. This critical density means the universe neither collapses under hyperbolic conditions (density < 1) nor halts expansion under spherical conditions (density > 1). Instead, it continues to expand at a decelerating rate without ever stopping.
The exact reasons behind the universe's critical matter density remain elusive. The universe encompasses three primary types of matter: baryonic matter (the conventional matter), dark matter, and an unidentified third form termed dark energy. While dark matter's existence is inferred from galactic behaviors, dark energy is observed only through the universe's expansion, prompting the introduction of the cosmological constant into Einstein's equations to maintain the critical density.
The BHBBT offers a solution to the flatness problem by linking the interior of the black hole to a de Sitter space, which represents our universe with infinite temporal possibilities. As an observer approaches the singularity, they transition into this de Sitter space, continuing for an infinite duration. Notably, the only method to connect a de Sitter space to a black hole involves a flat topology.
Black Hole Information Paradox
One more aspect to consider is the black hole information paradox. This theory suggests that quantum information, represented by quantum particle states falling into a black hole, vanishes from the observable universe. In the BHBBT, this information does not disappear; rather, it transitions from the mother universe to the daughter universe.
Is This Theory Valid?
At present, the SBB model presents numerous challenges, containing only elements that can be rigorously tested through experimentation and observation. The BHBBT emerges as a compelling theory that can be coherently articulated within the framework of Einstein's General Relativity, requiring no new physics. It also provides an explanation for the occurrence of the Big Bang itself and offers intriguing philosophical implications, such as insights into the anthropic principle and the reasons for our existence. However, it is essential to note that the theory remains unproven empirically.
The first video, "Could The Universe Be Inside A Black Hole?" explores the implications of the idea that our universe may be contained within a black hole.
The second video, "Brian Greene - Did The Universe Emerge Inside a Black Hole?" delves into the relationships between black holes and the origins of universes.
Like this narrative? Subscribe to The Infinite Universe for updates on new articles. Check out "The Infinite Universe," available on Amazon.