Chapter 1: The Concept of a Jurassic Park

Is it possible to establish a Jurassic Park? While actual dinosaurs may be out of reach, the idea of creating hybrid creatures, dubbed "chickensaurus," might not be entirely far-fetched. The question arises: why pursue this?

Recently, Max Hodak, a biomedical engineer and co-founder of Neuralink, reignited interest in this captivating topic. His statement, which circulated widely, suggested, "We could probably set up a Jurassic Park if we wanted to. They wouldn't be genetically authentic dinosaurs, but who knows? Maybe it will take 15 years of breeding and engineering to create new, exotic species."

Hodak’s comments sparked discussions, but he clarified that he wasn’t referencing a Neuralink initiative. Instead, he was reflecting on the broader scientific landscape, which has been exploring these possibilities for years, influenced in part by the cultural legacy of the 1993 film Jurassic Park. The film’s narrative also serves as a cautionary tale, highlighting the potential hazards of resurrecting massive carnivorous creatures.

In the movie, the premise is that dinosaurs could be revived through cloning fragments of their DNA, extracted from ancient mosquitoes preserved in amber. This idea was inspired by a 1982 study from the University of California at Berkeley, which demonstrated amber's capacity to preserve the cellular structure of trapped organisms. Given the limited understanding of DNA at that time, the film’s premise was audacious yet not entirely implausible.

The film also introduced another compelling scientific notion: the potential for creating hybrid animals through genetic engineering. In the storyline, the DNA retrieved from mosquitoes was incomplete due to degradation, necessitating the use of amphibian DNA to fill in the gaps.

However, modern science clarifies that recreating dinosaurs as depicted in Jurassic Park presents numerous challenges. The primary hurdle is the unavailability of genuine prehistoric DNA, as the degradation of organic material over millions of years renders it nearly impossible to recover viable samples.

British paleontologist Susannah Maidment explained, "While we have preserved mosquitoes from the time of the dinosaurs in amber, these specimens mostly retain the outer layers, not the soft tissues. Therefore, we do not find blood in these mosquitoes." Fossilized mosquitoes can be discovered in sedimentary rock, but even these samples are too recent to provide information about dinosaurs, which went extinct approximately 20 million years prior.

Even if dinosaur blood could be recovered, the fragility of DNA poses a significant issue. DNA molecules degrade rapidly, making them unsuitable for cloning. Additionally, any recoverable DNA fragments are likely to be contaminated, complicating the process of isolating a genuine dinosaur genome further.

The cloning of extinct species from genetic samples also poses challenges. Even if a dinosaur genome could be reconstructed from tiny DNA fragments and chromosomes, transferring them into an egg cell remains problematic. There are no modern vertebrates closely related enough to dinosaurs for this process to work.

Hodak hints at this genetic "imperfection" when he discusses genetically inauthentic dinosaurs and "new super exotic species." Continuing with this speculative scenario, birds, rather than frogs, might be more suitable for filling in the genetic gaps of dinosaurs. Current theories suggest that birds evolved from theropods, a group that includes the infamous Tyrannosaurus rex, the only theropods to survive the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction.

Jack Horner, a renowned paleontologist and scientific consultant for the Jurassic Park films, proposed an intriguing alternative in his 2009 book, How to Build a Dinosaur. He suggests using genetic engineering techniques to modify chicken embryos, resulting in creatures with anatomical traits reminiscent of dinosaurs.

Horner's approach essentially aims to "reverse" evolution, reactivating dormant genes in birds that were silenced by natural selection. While this method may yield results, it is clear that no genetic manipulation will transform a chicken embryo into a full-fledged spinosaurus, nor will any resulting "chickensaurus" be a true dinosaur.

"Evolution is largely stochastic; it can take various paths. It's more likely that any return to dinosaur-like creatures would occur in reverse, considering that the necessary genetic building blocks already exist," notes Jamal Nasir, a geneticist at the University of Northampton.

Chapter 2: The Ethical Implications of Resurrecting Extinct Species

Ultimately, any attempts to create a Jurassic Park would be thwarted by the unyielding absence of suitable genetic material and living species necessary for genetic engineering. In contrast, efforts to recreate a portion of the megafauna from a "Pleistocene Park" by resurrecting the woolly mammoth, a species that went extinct around 5,000 years ago, may prove more feasible due to the existing genomic data available.

However, this endeavor also raises significant ethical questions. Is it responsible to recreate animals that resemble dinosaurs or other extinct species? David Ehrenfeld, a biology professor at Rutgers University, pointed out that "des-extinction" may only apply to a limited number of species, and the financial costs could divert resources from existing conservation efforts that are already underfunded.

On the other hand, the unpredictable nature of scientific discovery makes it difficult to ascertain the potential benefits of such research. Many funds awarded to Horner's team were utilized for studies on embryonic development in chickens, which could yield breakthroughs in treating spinal diseases or rare tumors.

As Jurassic Park reminds us, there is always a risk that things could go awry—“life finds a way.” Numerous questions must be addressed beforehand to avoid unexpected consequences later. As Ian Malcolm, played by Jeff Goldblum, famously stated, "The scientists were so preoccupied with whether they could do it, they didn't stop to think if they should."

Thank you for reading! If you found this exploration of Jurassic Park's feasibility intriguing, consider joining Medium for unlimited access to articles.